Medical Providers Assignment for Third-Party Liability Insurance Proceeds is Unenforceable

Medical Providers Assignment for Third-Party Liability Insurance Proceeds is Unenforceable

Action Chiropractic Clinic v. Prentice Delon Hyler,
2014 Tenn. App. LEXIS 73 (Tenn. Ct. App.  Feb. 12, 2014)

 

On October 24, 2011, William Burnette crashed his vehicle into Prentice Hyler. Burnette was insured by Erie Insurance Exchange. Hyler was injured in the accident and received medical treatment from Action Chiropractic Clinic. In exchange for the medical treatment, Hyler executed an assignment of rights to Action Chiropractic for medical expenses allowable and payable to Hyler from any “…auto insurance or any other party involved.” Erie/Burnette settled with Hyler for $8,510 and Hyler executed a release of all claims. Action Chiropractic then sent the assignment to Erie and demanded that Erie reimburse Action Chiropractic for $5,010 in outstanding medical bills. Erie refused and Action Chiropractic sued.

The Court, in affirming the dismissal of Action Chiropractic’s case, holds that the assignment between Hyler and Action Chiropractic could not be enforceable against Erie under Tennessee Code Annotated § 56-7-120 since Hyler was not within the category of individuals covered under Erie’s insurance policy. Moreover, while Hyler had a common law right to assign his “rights” to Action Chiropractic, Erie was not obligated to honor the assignment because Hyler did not have any “rights” under the Erie insurance policy that could be assigned to action and subsequently enforced.

 

Sean W. Martin, is a shareholder in the Chattanooga, Tennessee office of Carr Allison.  Sean can be reached at swmartin@carrallison.com or (423) 648-9834. 

News

Martin Awarded Defense Lawyer of the Year

Shareholder Sean W. Martin (Chattanooga, TN) has been named the 2019 Defense Lawyer of the Year!  Announced at the 53rd Annual Meeting of the Tennessee Defense Lawyers Association (TDLA), the award is given to the TDLA member who has made significant contributions to advancing the civil defense practice in Tennessee.  […]

Learn More

Lockett Named 2020 Best Lawyers “Lawyer of the Year” in Mobile

Learn More

Martin and Petherick Author Amicus Brief for TN Supreme Court

Shareholder Sean W. Martin and Associate Michael J. Petherick from Carr Allison’s Chattanooga (TN) office authored an amicus curiae brief on behalf of the Tennessee Defense Lawyers Association in the case of Jodi McClay v. Airport Management Services LLC.  The amicus brief supported the constitutionality of the Tennessee statute which […]

Learn More